Magic Ball

Think of a yes or no question, then tap Shake.

What the Magic Ball can say

There are 20 answers, and each one has the same chance, one in 20. They come in three groups:

  • 10 lean yes, like “Go for it” and “Sure thing”
  • 5 dodge the question, like “Ask me later” and “Shake again”
  • 5 lean no, like “Not this time” and “Nope”

So any single shake has a 50% chance of a yes, a 25% chance of a dodge and a 25% chance of a no. The full list is at the bottom of this page. Nothing is hidden.

Why the ball leans yes

If you’ve shaken a Magic 8 Ball, you’ll know how this works. We built ours to lean yes on purpose: half of the 20 answers say yes, because an answer ball should be an encouraging toy.

For a straight 50/50, use the yes or no wheel. Two answers, one pointer, nothing in between.

How it picks

When you tap Shake, your browser’s random number generator picks one of the 20 answers. The ball doesn’t read your question, and it doesn’t remember your last shake. Ask the same thing five times and you’ll get five separate picks.

We checked. We shook it a million times: every answer came up between 4.96% and 5.04% of the time (a fair one in 20 is 5%), and yes landed 50.01% of the time. We did the same with our yes or no wheel and wrote up what we found.

Some odds worth knowing

These are just math from the 20 answers:

  • Two yeses in a row: 1 in 4.
  • A dodge, then another dodge: 1 in 16. Two in a row is just chance.
  • Five shakes with no yes at all: 1 in 32.

That last one is the useful one. If you keep shaking until you get the answer you wanted, you will get it. Notice how many shakes it took, and how you felt while you waited.

When to use it

Jeane always wanted one of these as a kid and never got one. The answer ball she remembers is the one at the advertising agency where she worked. When the team was stuck on who would pitch a campaign to a client, or which idea would launch, somebody shook the ball. It got a lot of use.

The ball is for the small stuff, and for fun: what to watch, whether to text back tonight or tomorrow, who goes first.

Don’t ask it about money, health or anything you can’t take back. It’s a toy with a random pick inside, and it doesn’t know anything about your life.

Other tools

Want a third option on a wheel? Try the Yes, No or Maybe Wheel. Deciding whether to do something at all? Should I do it?

Questions people ask

Is this connected to the toy?

No. The Magic Ball is our own, with our own answers. Magic 8 Ball is a trademark of Mattel, and this site isn’t connected to Mattel.

Are the answers the same as the toy’s?

No. The words are ours. The mix is 10 that lean yes, 5 that dodge and 5 that lean no.

Can it see my question?

No. You don’t type it anywhere. Think it, then shake.

All 20 answers

Lean yes: Go for it, That’s a yes, Looks good to me, Odds say yes, I’d say yes, A clear yes, Yep, All signs: yes, Do it, Sure thing.

Dodge: Ask me later, Too foggy to say, Shake again, Not sure yet, Sleep on it.

Lean no: I wouldn’t, That’s a no, Not this time, Doubtful, Nope.

More ideas for using a yes or no wheel

More wheels

Pick the one that fits the question.

Pin It on Pinterest